🎉 You unlocked 15% off your order! 🎉

Discount applies automatically at checkout

of — Spend for 15% discount! You need more to save 15%! Keep going! Only away from 15% off! Almost there! to unlock 15% off! So close! Just to go!

Vintage Toys, Action Figures & Collectibles

Chillicothe Market at 1222 Western Ave. in Chillicothe, Ohio, carries vintage and collectible toys alongside our everyday resale finds: 1980s wrestling figures, sealed horror movie figures, classic board games, play sets, dolls and more. Most pieces are one of a kind, so when something sells it is gone.

What we look for

  • Action figures: 1980s WWF LJN wrestlers, McFarlane Movie Maniacs and other horror figures, many still factory sealed.
  • Dolls & play sets: Barbie, Colorforms, Kenner and Mattel sets from the 1980s and 1990s.
  • Games & lunch boxes: classic Milton Bradley board games, metal lunch boxes and nostalgic kids' items.

Browse everything in Toys & Games and Figures & Dolls, or see more collectibles like VHS tapes and vintage glassware.

In stock now

WWF LJN Rowdy Roddy Piper Wrestling Figure Original Kilt Poster Cards Vintage 84 - Main
WWF LJN Rowdy Roddy Piper Wrestling Figure Original Kilt Poster Cards Vintage 84
$129.98
WWF LJN Hulk Hogan Wrestling Figure Original Belt Poster Cards Vintage 1980s - Main
WWF LJN Hulk Hogan Wrestling Figure Original Belt Poster Cards Vintage 1980s
$144.98
WWF LJN British Bulldogs Tag Team Figures 1986 Original Belts Poster Vintage - Main
WWF LJN British Bulldogs Tag Team Figures 1986 Original Belts Poster Vintage
$199.97
McFarlane Toys Movie Maniacs Friday the 13th Jason Voorhees Action Figure 1998 - Main
McFarlane Toys Movie Maniacs Friday the 13th Jason Voorhees Action Figure 1998
$22.98
McFarlane Toys Movie Maniacs 2 Child's Play 2 Chucky Action Figure 1999 Sealed - Main
McFarlane Toys Movie Maniacs 2 Child's Play 2 Chucky Action Figure 1999 Sealed
$27.98
McFarlane Toys Movie Maniacs 2 Halloween Michael Myers Figure Factory Sealed - Main
McFarlane Toys Movie Maniacs 2 Halloween Michael Myers Figure Factory Sealed
$29.98
McFarlane Toys Movie Maniacs 2 Norman Bates Psycho Action Figure Sealed New - Main
McFarlane Toys Movie Maniacs 2 Norman Bates Psycho Action Figure Sealed New
$22.98
McFarlane Toys Movie Maniacs 2 Scream Ghost Face 1999 Figure Factory Sealed - Main
McFarlane Toys Movie Maniacs 2 Scream Ghost Face 1999 Figure Factory Sealed
$29.98
McFarlane Toys Movie Maniacs 4 Freddy Krueger Figure 2001 2nd Edition Sealed - Main
McFarlane Toys Movie Maniacs 4 Freddy Krueger Figure 2001 2nd Edition Sealed
$31.98
Kenner Fairy Winkles Secret Treasure Jewelry Box Playset 1993 No. 65012 - Main
Kenner Fairy Winkles Secret Treasure Jewelry Box Playset 1993 No. 65012
$89.98
New Mattel Disney The Lion King Jungle Friend Babies Playground Playset 11670 - Main
New Mattel Disney The Lion King Jungle Friend Babies Playground Playset 11670
$64.98
Mother Goose Basket Full of Rhymes Nursery Rhyme Metal Lunch Box - Main
Mother Goose Basket Full of Rhymes Nursery Rhyme Metal Lunch Box
$14.98
1981 Smurfs Smurf Land Colorforms Super Deluxe Play Set #4115 Factory Sealed - Front
1981 Smurfs Smurf Land Colorforms Super Deluxe Play Set #4115 Factory Sealed
$119.98
Mattel Barbie Fashion Model Collection The Lingerie Doll Silkstone 56120 - Main
Mattel Barbie Fashion Model Collection The Lingerie Doll Silkstone 56120
$159.98
Vintage Sesame Street Kookie Cookie Game Milton Bradley Unused Open Box 4011 - Main
Vintage Sesame Street Kookie Cookie Game Milton Bradley Unused Open Box 4011
$24.98
1989 Freddy Krueger Talking Doll Nightmare on Elm Street Factory Sealed Works - Front
1989 Freddy Krueger Talking Doll Nightmare on Elm Street Factory Sealed Works
$299.98

Buy online or in store

Order online and pick up for free at the store, or we ship anywhere in the U.S. Want to see a piece first? Visit us: open Monday to Friday 10 am to 4 pm and weekends 10 am to 2 pm. Have vintage toys to sell? Contact us about consignment.

1222 Western Ave.
Chillicothe, Ohio, 45601
(740) 666-4845
Mon-Fri: 10am-4pm
Sat-Sun: 10am-2pm
 

Good deals are meant to be shared.

Spread the word about Chillicothe Market and help your friends score amazing local finds.

We accept
© 2026 Chillicothe Market. All rights reserved.